Learn the truth about the Chapter 58 Massachusetts insurance mandate law

False health reform hurts residents

Help reject Chapter 58

See the Law Index

What the Law Says - Affordability

The law says that insurance must be "affordable". This word is used 7 times in the law itself. See the definition for "affordable"

What this means

The State has decided what is affordable and will not take individual needs into account. The affordability rates are based on boardroom formulas that have nothing to do with real people in real life. The State doesn't care about your particular housing, heating, debt, education, transportation, retirement savings or other needs.


What the Law Says -  The Appeals Process

The law stipulates that there must be a "generous" appeals process if a person believes they cannot afford the insurance. 

What this means

You are guilty, and the road to proving you are innocent is long and arduous. Your life is no longer your own, and there are no sacred cows. There is no “generous” appeals process. 

Excerpt from the Connector Certificate of Exemption TY08 Application: “To be considered for a Certificate of Exemption, you must demonstrate that you cannot afford a Connector health insurance product [Commonwealth Choice] because you experienced at least one qualifying financial hardship event during the time you were uninsured. If you are eligible for Commonwealth Care, MassHealth, Medicare, Veteran's Administration Program Enrollment, Fishing Partnership Health Plan, TRICARE, Qualified Student Health Insurance Program or the Massachusetts Division of Unemployment Assistance Medical Security Program, you cannot apply for a Certificate of Exemption.”

Massachusetts-style health insurance 
is NOT what 
the doctor
 ordered!

Health Care is a right for all

Persons who are eligible for Commonwealth Care and the other above programs will be denied an exemption because they are considered able to obtain health insurance. This means that, if you are eligible for Commonwealth Care, etc., but do not enroll in it, you will be subject to the penalty. 

The only way to get around this if you are in the 0% to 300% FPL bracket is to file for a "hardship appeal." This part of the law stipulates that the individual will have already have paid a huge amount of his or her income for "allowable medical services." Otherwise, there is no way to appeal and show that you cannot afford the extra expense.  See the exact wording of the law here.

For those in the group above 300% FPL, there is an appeals process that is limited to such hardship events as being in foreclosure for more than 30 days or eviction court, receiving utility shut-off notices for non-payment, being a victim of domestic violence and more horrible life events. See here for the full list of the specific calamities that ‘may' allow for this short-term, one-time exemption.

First you must prove that one of these catastrophic "hardships" has occurred. If the state decides that your "hardship" isn't real or bad enough, there can be severe legal and financial punishments. This is a deep and expensive bureaucratic maze meant to confuse, bewilder and deny.

The state has hired a team of 28 lawyers to make "hardship" determinations. The process involves: 
1) applying for an application, 2) filing for and submitting a confusing and intrusive, multi-page form, 3) waiting 2 to 3 months to see if the appeal is successful. If it is unsuccessful, you will be held liable for non-compliance penalties and owe for the entire time that the appeal was pending. (Hint: send it by certified mail, return receipt requested and check frequently that they still have your appeal as there have been many instances of lost documents and administrative errors.) See Connector Certificate of Exemption TY08 Application here .The 2009 form is not yet available.

» Read the next "What the Law Says" topic
 
» See the Law Topic Index 


The Individual Mandate explained  /  The Connector Authority  /  Affordability  /  The Appeals Process 

Religious Exemption  /  Income estimation  /  Tax enforcement and Criminal penalties  /  Data Gathering

Estate Recovery  /  Insurance plan "lock-in"  /  State as health insurance  Primary Care Shortage